ROASTool

Software spend calculator

SaaS ROI Calculator: Is That Subscription Actually Worth It?

Put the seat price and setup cost against the hours the tool saves and see the year-one return, the net gain and how fast onboarding pays for itself.

Year one return

+120%
Worth it
Cost / year
$4,320
Value / month
$1,600
Net gain / year
$14,880
Setup payback
0.4 mo

Every team has a spreadsheet of subscriptions and no idea which ones earn their keep. This SaaS ROI calculator compares what a tool costs — per seat, per month, plus onboarding — against the hours it saves and any revenue it can be credited with, and returns a year-one figure and a payback period.

"It saves time" is not a business case

Time saved only becomes money when one of three things happens: the hours turn into work you would otherwise have paid someone for, the same team ships more without new hires, or the tool removes a cost outright. If the saved hours just become a slightly calmer Tuesday, the subscription is a convenience purchase, not an investment.

That is why the calculator asks for a blended hourly cost. Take a salary, add 25–35% for benefits, taxes and overheads, divide by actual working hours. A $60,000 role works out around $38 an hour loaded; a $120,000 engineer closer to $75. Using a salary divided by 2,080 hours understates the real cost and makes every tool look good.

What goes in each field

  1. Price per seat per month. The number on the pricing page, at the tier you actually need. Annual plans usually discount 15–20%, so divide the yearly figure by twelve.
  2. Seats. Count the people who will genuinely use it, then add 10%. Unused seats are the single most common way these budgets leak.
  3. Setup and training. Migration, onboarding, integrations, and the week where nobody is as fast as they were before.
  4. Hours saved per seat per month. Be conservative. A tool that saves an hour a day is saving 20 hours a month — almost always an exaggeration. Start at 3–5 hours and see if the answer still works.
  5. Extra revenue. Only count revenue you could defend in a meeting. "Better reporting might win us deals" is not a number.

A worked example

Eight seats at $45 a month is $3,600 a year, plus $600 of onboarding: $4,200. If each seat saves 4 hours a month at a $50 blended rate, that is $1,600 a month of value, or $19,200 a year. Year one net gain is $15,000 and the setup pays for itself in well under two months.

Now change one input. Suppose the team only saves one hour a month per seat. Monthly value falls to $400, the tool costs $360 a month, and the whole case collapses — a $40 a month saving is not worth a migration project. The difference between a great tool and a bad one is often just the number of hours people actually use it.

The costs people leave out

Cost Why it is easy to miss
Integration work Someone has to connect it to your data, usually a developer, usually for a week
Admin and renewal Permissions, offboarding, invoices, someone chasing the renewal date
Seat sprawl Seats get bought for a project and never removed
Switching cost Leaving later means exporting, retraining, migrating again
Tool overlap The thing often duplicates a feature you already pay for elsewhere

A practical rule: if the year-one ROI is under 50% after including setup, the case is too thin to survive a busy quarter. Under 0%, you either cut seats or cut the tool.

When a subscription clearly earns its keep

Tools that earn their place tend to share a shape: they replace work someone was already being paid to do, they are used daily by the whole team, and the alternative is hiring. Analytics, billing, support desks and CI minutes usually qualify. Design tools with three active seats out of twelve usually do not.

Buy versus build is the other comparison worth doing. A $45 a month tool costs $540 a year. Building the same thing internally costs a few weeks of engineering time, which at $75 an hour is $6,000 or more, plus maintenance forever. In almost every case, buying wins unless the tool is core to how you differentiate.

Run the numbers with your real seat count and a deliberately pessimistic hours-saved estimate. If it still clears, you have an answer you can defend at the next budget review.

SaaS ROI questions

How do I work out a blended hourly rate?

Add 25–35% to salary for benefits, taxes and overheads, then divide by actual working hours. A $60,000 role lands near $38 an hour, an engineer on $120,000 near $75. Using salary divided by 2,080 hours understates the cost.

How many hours saved is realistic?

Start with 3 to 5 hours per seat per month and check whether the case still works. A tool claiming an hour saved per day per person is claiming 20 hours a month, which almost never survives contact with a real team.

What ROI should a SaaS tool hit?

Above roughly 100% in year one, including setup costs, the tool is clearly worth it. Between 0 and 50% the case is thin and will probably be cut at the next budget review. Below zero, reduce seats before renewing.

Should I count every seat we pay for?

Count only about 10% more seats than current daily users. Seats bought for a project and never removed are the most common way software budgets grow without anyone deciding to spend more.

Is it cheaper to build our own?

Usually buying. A $45 a month tool costs $540 a year; building the same thing internally costs weeks of engineering time plus permanent maintenance. Build only when the functionality is core to what makes your product different.

More calculators